Hedge fund Balyasny is closed to new money. What about the $50m+ hiring?
Balyasny Asset Management (BAM) is like Goldilocks. After several years spent seeking an optimal amount of assets under management (AUM), it has decided it's just right. Business Insider reported yesterday that the firm has been telling investors it's closed to new money.
💥Follow us on WhatsApp for news alerts.💥
The closure comes after a period of heady growth. Once a cosy place where people referred to each other as "Bamily", Balyasny grew assets from around $16bn in May 2022 to around $37bn now. In the process, it roughly doubled investment headcount. In the past two years alone, Balyasny added 212 investment staff according to regulatory filings. Last year, it was the third most zealous hirer in percentage terms, behind Verition and Jain Global.
Some of Balyasny's portfolio manager hires have come with impressive price tags. In August 2024, Bloomberg reported that Balyasny was embarking on a $200m hiring spree. New equities hires like Peter Goodwin and Alberto Mann reportedly joined on packages worth $50m+. David Brodsky, a healthcare-focused PM from Citadel, reportedly joined on a similar amount despite an alleged $60m drawdown at Citadel.
Balyasny's recent hiring has been about diversification. Traditionally an equities-focused house, the fund has spread into areas like macro and commodities trading. This year, however, that hasn't worked out so well.
In the year to October, Balyasny lost 2.7% net of fees according to Bloomberg. In October, it lost another 3.4% before fees. It's a far cry from the heady days of 2020 when a less diversified version of Balyasny Asset Management generated returns of 33%.
Following October's macro brutality, some of Balyasny's previously prized hires have been leaving. Stanley Sheriff, a 33-year-old ex-Goldman Sachs macro trader whom Balyasny poached from rival fund Taula, left Balyasny again a few weeks ago. Sheriff was only at Balyasny for approximately 18 months. He spent less than two months at Taula and is thought to have been lured by an eight figure package to join Balyasny. It's thought he left by mutual agreement.
James Watson, whom Balyasny hired from Millennium in 2023 also left again last month. Watson, who was a senior macro portfolio manager at Balyasny, is returning to Millennium in a business management role. It's thought that Balyasny also paid eight figures for Watson, who arrived only in September 2024 and was active at the fund for barely two years. Millennium is thought to have wooed him back after what some say was a difficult year for his Balyasny team.
Balyasny is far from the only fund to lose macro portfolio managers this year; hundreds are out of the market. But with the fund closing to new investors and registering a loss for 2026, eyebrows are being raised at the expensive hiring past. Balyasny was "aggressive" in some of its hiring, say headhunters on both sides of the Atlantic. "In some cases," they paid more than other funds, says one headhunter. Another says junior PMs in particular appeared to have been well paid to join the Bamily.
In other cases, though, Balyasny was outbid. Millennium added the greatest number of investment professionals between 2022 and 2025, at 395 extra people. Those hires included Steven Schurr, a senior equities portfolio manager at Balyasny, whom Millennium reportedly hired for a $100m package in 2025. Balyasny presumably wanted to keep Schurr, who is said to have made $250m in profits for the firm in 2024, but its pockets don't appear to have been deep enough. Similarly, Millennium poached Max Witcher, another profitable equities PM from Balyasny in July.
In their defence, funds wafting eight figure packages typically point out that they are contingent upon performance and include money for team members plus the cost of buying out deferred bonuses from elsewhere. Quietly, though, headhunters say hedge fund pay has become "crazy" and that Balyasny has been just one of the funds participating in the madness.
What next? The decision to close to new cash looks like an admission that Balyasny needs to get a handle on its existing strategies before putting extra money to work in a crowded market. After a difficult year, the fund is still hiring - possibly to replenish its ranks, possibly to fulfil existing commitments. Balyasny recently added Arsenije Dusanic from Trafigura in Switzerland to trade oil. 30 other portfolio managers are thought to be in the pipeline and currently on gardening leave. The eight figure recruiting is not over yet.
Follow me on X. Follow me on LinkedIn.
Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: +44 7537 182250 (SMS, Whatsapp or voicemail). Telegram: @SarahButcher. Signal: sarahbutcher.22 Click here to fill in our anonymous form, or email editortips@efinancialcareers.com.
Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: comments are moderated intermittently by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. You must take sole responsibility for comments you post on this site. We will take reasonable steps to weed out anything that we consider to be offensive or inappropriate.