It’s been two days since the California Public Employees' Retirement System made headlines by announcing that it is pulling all the money it has invested in hedge funds. All $4 billion. The country’s largest public pension fund cited “cost” and “complexity” as its chief reasons for essentially firing two dozen hedge funds.
Since the announcement, people have been standing on opposite sides of the fence when it comes to what the move means for the hedge fund industry in general. On the one hand, $4 billion is just a drop in the bucket when you consider the industry currently manages an all-time record $2.8 trillion in assets. In a quantitative sense, the decision won’t move the meter an inch.
On the other hand, Calpers is a monster pension fund that tends to predict the behavior of other institutional investors, which hedge funds rely on more than ever. Individual wealth accounts for just a sliver of assets under management at most large hedge funds.
“The fact that Calpers is jumping off is an important time for reflection,” Rodger F. Smith, a managing director at Greenwich Associates, told the New York Times. What institutional investors are likely reflecting upon is the relative cost of dealing with hedge funds.
Most hedge funds attempt to apply the “2 and 20” pricing model, where they charge a 2% fee on any assets under management plus 20% of all annual investment profits. In reality, few are actually hitting their targets. The averages are said to be more like 18% for performance fees and 1.6% for annual charges.
That said, hedge funds have underperformed the market by a significant margin over the last two years. And it’s not just that they are hedging safely in a bull market. A Barclays’ index of traditional bond funds is outperforming the average hedge fund this year, Richard Beales keenly points out. That shouldn’t be happening in the current market.
However, not all funds are the same. If you look at the 24 hedge funds and six hedge fund-of-funds that Calpers employed, they didn’t exactly do a bang up job. An annualized rate of 4.8% over the last decade. Calpers reportedly used its leveraged as a monster pension fund to convince funds to offer below-market fees. It seems they went shopping at a discount store and paid the price.
Likely, the hedge fund industry is plenty safe. If you’re good, people will stay. If you’re mediocre, they’ll leave. But the Calpers situation will give investors more leverage when it comes to the fees they pay. Even good hedge funds may need to be more flexible this time around. Some institutional investors have already signaled that they’re preparing for that conversation.
How Women React to Gender Bias Today (eFinancialCareers)
A shocking percentage of women who said gender discrimination exists at their own firm would still recommend their company to a female acquaintance.
Masters Or MBA? (eFinancialCareers)
If you want to get a postgraduate qualification that will get you job in banking, should you go for an MBA or a Masters in Finance? That depends upon whether you’re based on Wall Street or in the City of London.
Barclays in the Muck Again (Bloomberg)
Barclays reportedly continued to mask the role high-speed traders played in its dark pool after the bank said it had rid the pool of such activity, according to Attorney General Eric Schneiderman.
The Perils of Being One Kind of CIO (Dealbook)
Working as an investment officer at an institution with a large endowment and rabid alumni, like say a Harvard or Yale, isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. Think more pressure and smaller paychecks. Employee turnover continues to increase.
Stay Home (WSJ)
Boston-Based State Street reportedly told its head of spot foreign exchange trading in London to stay away from the office while the company conducts a review of its FX business. Simon Pepper isn’t suspended, it appears, but he isn’t working either.
Who to Follow on Twitter (Business Insider)
Here’s a neat list of 102 finance pros who you should be following on Twitter. I agree with most of them except Mohamed A. El-Erian. He’s kind of a snore. No acrimonious comments about his former boss.
BofA Sharpening the Axe (Financial News)
Apparently Bank of America is pruning more staff than we had originally thought. Roughly a dozen traders and bankers within its Asian arm were laid off this week. Cuts are also going down in New York, Houston and Chicago, mostly at the VP level.
Buzz Around the Office
Money Doesn’t Buy You Love (MTL Blog)
A Tinder user named Brandon posted a unique profile picture in an attempt to improve his dating life. Rather than dressing to impress, he simply took a screen shot of his rather healthy bank account.
Quote of the Day: “Twitter is hard to evaluate. They have a lot of potential. It’s a horribly mismanaged company — probably a lot of pot-smoking going on there.” – prominent venture capitalist Peter Thiel