Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Goldman Sachs may be most moral when paying redundant employees

Goldman Sachs: where the alluring bankers work

Goldman Sachs may be more principled than many other banks when it comes to paying bonuses to its employees who are being laid off. So says Charles Ferguson, a London-based employment lawyer who often works with disaffected traders.

"Goldman Sachs is an honorable bank in its dealings with its employees," said Ferguson. "They take the view that dealing with their people reasonably is in the bank's long term interest. For that reason, out of the hundreds of banks we've pursued over the years Goldman Sachs has only come across our screens on about three occasions - and at no time have we come across individuals from Goldman Sachs have felt they have been badly treated."

The latest manifestation of Goldman's honorableness is the bank's decision to cull its lowest performing employees only after its bonuses have been paid. Reuters reported that Goldman is clearing out the weakest 5% of its employees, with deeper cuts in areas like equities trading.

Goldman did not return a request to comment on its alleged redundancies or on its bonus payment date. However, headhunters told us that Goldman's bonuses have already been paid out. Our bonus calendar put Goldman's payment date at the end of January.

In clearing out poor performers only after bonuses have been paid, Goldman appears to be at odds with other banks like Barclays, which recently cleared the ranks of senior bankers days before its bonuses were announced. Similarly, UBS is said to be announcing layoffs in its investment bank before bonuses are paid in March.

By laying off staff before bonuses, banks can save themselves a lot of money. "Most banks will choose to get rid of staff before bonuses because they have a clause in their contracts which says staff are entitled to bonuses only if they are in employment and not under notice (given or received) at the time bonuses are paid," said Ronnie Fox at employment law specialists Fox Lawyers in London. The same principle applies in the US. “If there is a fully discretionary provision, there is really no recourse for the employee,” Joanne Seltzer, a partner in the New York City office of Jackson Lewis LLP, told us. 

Whether banks choose to clear out employees just before bonus time is a reflection of their honorableness, said Ferguson. "If your employer is not honorable, it will bin you shortly before the date your bonus is announced and it's just tough. If you're working for an entity that has pretensions to honor its moral obligations, your bonus will be paid first."

Ferguson declined to comment on which banks fire before bonuses, but said there is a distinct group of repeat offenders. Meanwhile, one headhunter pointed out that waiting until after bonuses are paid to make layoffs isn't so moral if the bonuses were zero. "There were quite a few zeroes among Goldman's bonuses this year," he added.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • ci
    cityhag
    26 February 2013

    Yup. Spot on. The GS bonus won't be mega - it's one of the ways you can see you're on the exit route, but it will be paid. UBS, on the other hand, will can you even after stellar performance, just before bonuses (it's never a couple of months - they want the sweat of your brow) and tell you you were sh*te to justify your boss grabbing the pot for himself.

  • Ba
    Barcap_guy
    26 February 2013

    What Barclays did this year was very low, something they haven't ever done before, and reflecting the unfortunate change of culture at the firm since the Lehman acquisition: Layoffs stretched across 3 days *just* before bonus day. And bonuses for the remaining 'lucky' employees were distributed in a way which had little to do with Bob Diamond's 'pay for performance' or the meritocracy he cherished. More according to the 'Friends & Family' principle.. Sad to see the firm take this path, it can't end well..

  • an
    anonymous
    26 February 2013

    Sure they ll ire you after bonus have been paid, but if you re going to be fired oh can be pretty certain our bonus would have been zero anyways!

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Boost your career

Find thousands of job opportunities by signing up to eFinancialCareers today.
Recommended Articles
Latest Jobs
Bloomberg
Legal Data Analyst - Citator Data Enrichment
Bloomberg
Princeton, United States
Selby Jennings
Senior C++ Engineer
Selby Jennings
New York, United States
Bloomberg
Financial Engineer - Enterprise Products
Bloomberg
New York, United States
Bloomberg
Network Operations Engineer
Bloomberg
San Francisco, United States
Bloomberg
BQuant Technical Writer - CTO Office
Bloomberg
San Francisco, United States

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.