Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

GUEST COMMENT: I’m astonished that banks still employ so many Indian technologists

IT contractors are sinking, but are Indian contractors really to blame? (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Before you say I’m racist, let me make one thing clear: I am Indian by lineage, although British by birth. I also work in technology.

My point, quite simply, is this: why do banking organisations employ such significant numbers of Indian contractors in their technology roles? It may have made sense in the past, but as far as I can see there is now absolutely no shortage of qualified technologists in the UK .

Clearly the argument in the past has been that Indian technologists are far less costly than their UK counterparts, but with UK graduates struggling to find work that price differential is eroding.

Yet my experience suggests banks continue to import contractors from India, to the detriment of morale in the UK and to the detriment of internal and external customer experience.  Many of the Indian contractors I’ve come across have shocking low levels of skill and competence that would be unacceptable were they not so cheaply priced. Some are unable to conduct business, except in their mother tongue.

At the same time, I know of many UK IT contractors who are struggling to stay afloat. All of them are very skilled and all are willing to be somewhat price-flexible in the current environment.

Yet they are being shut out of the market. Banks’ tendency to go for cheaply priced, low-skilled labour is killing the market. This is a shame. As a customer I also worry that my data is being handled by people with low levels of English – particularly after that the problems at RBS.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORAnonymous Insider Comment
  • ro
    rockstar
    18 September 2012

    it's high time that H1B visas for Indians and british workpermits for indians are heavily curtailed so that other nationalities can get a chance.

    time indians practiced birth control too.

    too many of them.....

  • ro
    rockstar
    18 September 2012

    please send them back

  • Wi
    WizardofEC1
    10 September 2012

    In my experience, sub-contractors from the sub-Continent are more trouble than they are worth.

    Their skills are very poor, their communication even worse, almost always requiring very close supervision and a substaintial amount of re-work by skilled professionals in order for the product to be market worthy.

    It is not a question of race - it is an observation of consistent failure.

    If anyone actually looked at the true overall cost of hiring these folks ( e.g. increased management involvement, rework etc), the price differential would be very interesting.

    There is no justification for bringing these people to the UK other than cost.

  • ms
    msieniaw
    10 September 2012

    @zooboo The whole world heard plenty of criticism directed at the UK - it is not illegal in this country. Read my post a bit more carefully before you respond.

  • CD
    CDOHero
    10 September 2012

    Because, my dear friend, despite its pretence of multiculturalism, the UK society is still dominated by prejudices and ancient beliefs of dominance of the East and West Indies, and the white man in charge feels more inclined to hire as contractors Indian technologists, as an expression of his superiority.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.