Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

90% of MBA graduates are employed within three months and most are earning 60% more than previously. Should you take an MBA, therefore?

The Economist has produced its ranking of the top 20 MBAs.

If you're thinking of reinvigorating your financial services career with a spot of studying this may come in helpful. In terms of European business schools, the Economist ranks IMD first, followed by IESE, followed by London Business School, HEC, ESADE, and INSEAD.

On paper, all these schools look great. Most have 90% or more of their graduates in employment three months after the course finishes (HEC is the outlier on 85%) and their MBA graduates far better off than they used to be. Most are at least 60% better off. At IESE they're 150% better off.

So, if you're already out of work, or expecting to be find yourself out of work imminently, why not enroll for an MBA right away? Not only will you be almost guaranteed employment, but you will benefit from a massive uplift in your compensation.

The first reason is, obviously, fees. It's becoming a lot harder to fund an MBA than it used to be. Neither HSBC nor Citi are providing loans to MBA students any more (which possibly says something about the problems people have been having paying them back). Insiders say schools are cutting course sizes as a result.

The second reason is immigration. Non-EU MBA students are currently able to remain within the UK for two years on a post-study work visa and can then switch to a Tier Two general visa without eating into banks' immigration quotas. But this may change. "The real problem is that no one knows what will happen after April next year," says Jonathan Goldsworthy at law firm Bird & Bird.

The third and biggest reason is the meaningfulness of figures produced by business schools for MBA graduate employment and salary levels. MBA careers services talk of big pressure to get people into jobs within three months in order to look good on rankings such as those produced by the Economist and the Financial Times..

"That three month employment figure has a big impact on business schools' revenues," says one MBA careers advisor. "Schools have been forced to work much harder at making students pragmatic and realistic in order that they will accept the jobs on offer and be in work by the right date."

Equally, salary increases post-MBA can be inflated when a large proportion of students come from low paying roles overseas. "Someone who's earning $40k in India and who finds a role in London is going to get a big percentage increase," points out the consultant.

In their defence, MBA schools say opinionated students can't be compelled to accept unappealing jobs simply to satisfy the three month employment target and that the range of financial services employers looking for MBAs has increased. "Rothschild, Lloyds and Standard Chartered have all expanded their MBA programmes this year," says one MBA careers advisor. "MBA students are still a comparatively cheap way for banks to hire experienced talent," he points out.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • MB
    MBAaspirations
    1 November 2011

    @SSSS Quite an unbelievable attitude. Registering to study an MBA in the UK (usually) entitles you to a world class course and lecturers to enhance your career - nowhere in that transaction is an entitlement to live there.

  • Sa
    Sarah, Editor, eFinancialCaree
    19 October 2011

    @It worked for me! Do you want to get in touch - we're writing something on you....

    editor@eFinancialCareers.com.

    Thank you.

  • Pa
    Pavle
    19 October 2011

    Simple question:

    Taking away the argument that an MSc is more technical, should one take an MBA if one has an MSc and excellent experience?

  • SS
    SSSS
    18 October 2011

    @Sarah

    I Heard that there will be an alternative to the PSW but nothing is clear so far..the lawyer that I know doesnt have any clue..it seems that there is a lack of communication btw the government and the rest of the UK............one thing for sure it is a depressing time for students who come to the UK, pay lot of money for the course and then have no other choice than living the country...the government is robbing the students...

  • It
    It worked for me!
    18 October 2011

    Having completed an MBA at Cass which isn't even in the top 20, I can only draw on my personal experience but I was previously working in Middle Office (US IB) and am now working as a trader (hedge fund).

    Look, at the end of the day, an MBA like many other post-grad qualifications will only be as good as you allow it to be. If you only go to the standard careers fairs provided by the school and apply for the roles the school provides then the chances of getting what you want will be diminished significantly. I must have sent out well over 100 CVs, networked as much as possible and generally did everything I could think of to maximise my chances. Again, maybe I was just lucky particularly as I had a small amount of trading experience that I could leverage however, I do believe that MBAs still possess value. I would say that people should think about career avenues, IB (ie CF, M&A etc) is a less viable option in general as banks have cut headcount and if you're career switching, unless you are a genius with impeccable academics, it will be difficult.

    But then again, I always start from the point of view that I would rather regret doing something than nothing.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.