Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Michael Page provides a very detailed account of its business model

As we have said, Michael Page revealed its results this week and its share price promptly plunged.

Aside from the precipitous reduction in the value of the company, there were other things of note at the time of Michael Page's revelations. Included in its results was some detailed stuff on how the business of recruitment actually works. This, we have summarized as follows:

1) Almost all the costs are staff costs

75% of Michael Page's cost base 'relates' to its staff. This is considerably more than at an investment bank. The implication would appear to be that in a weak revenue environment, recruiters are even more at risk than bankers.

Michael Page admits as much, saying: "The main opportunity for reducing our own cost base is headcount."

2) It takes a while before new recruiters are up to much

When revenues increase, Michael Page initially relies on its existing 'infrastructure' to grow and then hires new people. However, "it takes time to train staff before they become fully productive." This inhibits its ability to grow revenues in any one quarter.

3) Recruiters like Michael Page only make money when they actually make a placement

As a contingency recruiter, Michael Page doesn't make money when it sifts through CVs. It doesn't make money when it provides banks with a short list. It doesn't make money when it sends candidates for interview and debriefs them afterwards.

It only makes money when a bank actually hires one of its candidates. And if a client cancels an 'assignment' at any stage in the process, it won't get paid.

Successful placements are a small minority of cases. For the first six months of 2011, Michael Page's 'conversion rate' (the % of the jobs it started working on which it was actually paid for) was a mere 16.5%.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • Pa
    Paul
    20 August 2011

    We could still do with a bit of a definition of "started working on". There's a big difference between having a quick half hour's headhunt on a role you've heard might be coming up and committing significant time and resource to an exclusive role.

    And this is not detailed in the slightest, as all have said.

  • Sa
    Sarah, Editor, eFinancialCaree
    19 August 2011

    @Mark - I fully appreciate and totally embrace your sentiment that PRs are not neutral. But they are usually able to explain the meaning of a phrase in an investor release.

  • Ma
    Mark
    19 August 2011

    @Sarah, I was being facetious re the PR because the concept seemed so absurdly ludicrous. The thought that you cite or rather infer that a PR company employed by Michael Page is a valid (reliable/neutral) source of information would surely rankle with any readers following this thread.

  • Sa
    Sarah, Editor, eFinancialCaree
    19 August 2011

    @Mark - I've altered the definition to clarify that the conversion rate is the percentage of roles MP starts working on which it's paid for. I assume this includes all roles. The PR is not a joke.

  • Ma
    Mark
    19 August 2011

    @Sarah - 16.5% Conversion rate in terms of Jobs given to Michael Page by clients. So this conversion rate in fact has nothing to do with registered candidates, do you nothing think this is completely misleading?

    Moreover, the 16.5% is a complete anomaly based on the very definition and interpretation of a "job" by Michael Page.

    Does a Temp/Contract position count towards this figure or is this based solely based on Permanent positions? Also what about a position where a client is looking to hire 5 people with the same Job Spec, does this go on their system as 1 or 5 mandates?

    These are some basic questions I would have expected anyone to ask an Analyst. For the most part by the way, Analysts are very poorly informed about how recruitment works and essentially go on the information provided (by said firm) and the inevitable bottom line P&L. As for the PR, I presume this was you making a joke?

    In BREAKING NEWS today the PR firm employed by Michael Page state "Michael Page are super duper, look at their amazing stats"

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.