Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

GUEST COMMENT: A small anecdote illustrating the importance of behaving ethically

You can only be betrayed by those you trust, everything else is just business.

Being a headhunter and worse still, one that specialises in bankers, it may strike you as odd that I'm writing an article on ethics, but I believe that a view from the bottom is as valid as the one from the top, where you no doubt sit.

This article was inspired by a conversation with someone about their first job straight out of university. Their team had a stand at a conference and they had the standard "put you business card in this bucket for a chance to win a very big bottle of champagne," display. At the end of the conference, the newly promoted head of sales packed the cards for future reference, opened the bottle and shared it around the junior staff who'd worked on the stand.

Now, these were also mostly people who were in their first job. And in their eyes, the clear signal transmitted by the sharing of the champagne was this and the clear signal being sent was this: since there was no one person who could possibly complain that they didn't get the champagne, it was ok to drink it themselves.

The head of sales may not have realised it, but in behaving this way, he was storing up trouble for himself in future. The reason most people don't do the bad things they could do is that they choose not to having been socialised into accepting that some things are unacceptable.

In this situation, the manager was signalling that unethical behaviour is acceptable. And given that opportunities to shaft the competition are rare, but that opportunities to shaft customers and team members are far more frequent, he was likely to be the main victim of this in future. It's hard to see his career thriving as a result.

Dominic Connor is a Director of P&D Quant Recruitment and teaches Ethics to Quants on the Wilmott CQF

author-card-avatar
AUTHORDominic Connor Insider Comment
  • An
    Anna
    24 August 2011

    "And given that opportunities to shaft the competition are rare, but that opportunities to shaft customers and team members are far more frequent, he was likely to be the main victim of this in future."

    You are right and I give you credit for this. But no one cares. Everyone knows IBs screw their customers - all night long!

    To quote a global head of industry M&A at a certain top bulge bracket bank: "Scum always rises to the top". He was right.

  • Pr
    Pro
    24 August 2011

    j, Davros and Ricky=Domic Connor.
    We are angry because we expect high quality non-trivial articles on this website. We are all typically well educated and aware of the culture within the workplace; this article is an insult to our intelligence, if you felt we would feel 'satisfied' and 'educated' after reading such bull.

    Also Dominic, if you notice it is not just this article; but many articles that you write that attract such negative criticism and reader backlashes. Why don't you take the hint?

  • Ri
    Ricky
    23 August 2011

    Not a bad article and although I don't like recruiters I'm not going to anonomously bad mouth Dominic as I've never met him. What's more telling however are the reams of bitter comments from the washed up detritus of the banking world and the unemployed graduate dreamers who have been missold the banking dream. How you can get so angry and twisted about a harmless article is beyond me.

  • Da
    Davros
    23 August 2011

    Fair point well made. You lead from the top. If senior staff behave like this, even on something trivial, it sets the tone for the rest of the organisation be it a whole company or a team. If you're willing to fiddle a raffle, its not such a leap to fiddle PnL.

    Ethics aside, he also broken the golden rule of duplicitiy , if you are going to do something dodgy, don't tell anyone.

  • j
    j
    23 August 2011

    Interesting reactions above. But a valid point. The team has learned some valuable lessons. First, don't share your business card for nothing, second, the boss is not to be trusted. Perhaps they should have known that already, perhaps others have forgotten the time when they did not take that for granted.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.