Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

As jobseekers soar, a recruitment agency says it's unable to help 85% of the applicants who send in their CVs

Much as financial services recruitment firms would like to place every single individual hopeful candidate who comes to them for help, they're having to be increasingly selective about who they work with.

Yesterday, recruitment firm Astbury Marsden estimated that the number of new financial services vacancies in London fell 11% month on month in July, whilst the number of new candidates rose 32%.

Today, Astbury Marsden COO Mark Cameron told us: "We get thousands of CVs every month and of those we probably only work with 15%.

"We will pick and choose who we put in front of clients," Cameron informed us.

Arguably this is inevitable: recruiters exist to sift out good candidates for their clients, but it also illustrates precisely how hard it is to get noticed nowadays.

On the other hand, contractors are booming

While it's becoming harder to get a permanent position in a bank, it's becoming easier to get a contract role in the back and middle office.

Cameron said Astbury Marsden's contractor numbers have doubled over the past 12-18 months. And the head of another recruitment firm gravely informs us that quite a few of the permanent roles they're getting have already been assigned to favoured contractors.

"There hasn't been a big drop off in terms of new jobs, but there are some underlying issues," he confides. "Some line managers want to move their favourite contractors into permanent employment, but they are often obliged to advertise the role externally to see if they can find someone cheaper."

The implication would therefore appear to be that you need to try contracting if you want to get new permanent employment soon.

Maybe.

However, Jo Phillips, manager in the banking and financial services division at Badenoch & Clark says this is not true at all and that most of the clients she works with go to "great pains" to try and find an internal candidate before advertising for people externally.

Excitingly, Phillips also maintained that things are improving: "We've seen a pick up in hiring activity this week. It's a few weeks into the school holidays and some decision makers are back in the office."

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • Sc
    Scum
    15 August 2011

    I wasn't going to rise to the bait initially, but I think there are some ignorant, unfounded comments here that need addressing.
    First, a disclaimer. There are a lot of poor quality recruiters out there, but also a lot of good ones. It's actually your job to distinguish which are which (subjective as often failing to get a job becomes the fault of the recruiter rather than accepting blame oneself)

    Often a headhunter will have limited amount of info on a candidate before he calls, they want to find more out but usually need the "hook" of a job to get a bite. If that role is not suitable why not discuss your background as they might have ANOTHER JOB.
    Referrals, why give them? first off, it's not lazy, it's their job to get candidates and referrals make part of that process. Who knows someone else may have had a call about your dream job, wouldn't you rather they referred you???
    Remember, you don't pay a candidate, the client does, so the recruiter HAS to deal with those with skills the client requests. Is it a recruiters job to help you use transferable skills to get into a new industry? Not really, it might be a by-product, but you didn't pay them to provide this service.

  • ma
    manager
    13 August 2011

    @Ed 'such a fast-paced and pressurised environment as financial services recruitment'

    Haha.. You must be joking! fast-paced? pressurised? Most recruiters are so stupid they would not last a day in a real job in the financial industry.

  • Mr
    MrAngry
    12 August 2011

    @EXBond and Pathfinder - why can you not understand that recruiters work for Clients who have very specific expectations? We influence, negotiate and persuade where we can (as its in our commercial interests to open the pool up and thus place more candidates) but we cannot change the criteria dramatically. I think you highlight a very real problem when you say that most people go to recruiters wanting a career change. This is why most recruiters have inboxes full of candidates they can't help. Work hard, educate yourself, network feverishly and you may make the switch. But don't expect to be presented to a business and role of which you have no experience by a recruiter who is only paid to find candidates that are as close to the Client-given brief as possible. Wake up and smell the coffee people!

  • GG
    GG
    12 August 2011

    @AD - Programme Managers, Project Managers, Vendor System Experts, Silverlight Developers, Dev Leads all 850+

    Even bog standard developers in the IB earn between 6-700pd - these figures are standard for Front Office technologists in the Banking realm.

    We have an FX IT Programme Manager at a Tier2 on 1300pd -

  • Pa
    Pathfinder
    12 August 2011

    @ ex bond trader - Recruiters are too stupid to help you in finding a new career path, all they can do is to see how many boxes your profile ticks.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.