Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Three weird types of candidate with a tendency to apply for financial services jobs

This is for anyone who's ever interviewed candidates during their careers. We are looking for anecdotes relating to the abnormality of individuals seeking jobs in financial services. Please post them below in the comments box.

In the meantime, here are a few examples to get the ball rolling.

The shady, silent type

We all know people working in technology can be strange, but we spoke to one recruiter recently who dealt with an IT professional who wore sunglasses (without explanation) throughout an interview. Worse still, he refused to answer any questions. "The bank wondered why the candidate even bothered coming for the interview. It's safe to say he didn't get the job," says the recruiter.

The Machiavellian manipulator

A back-office job seeker from a commercial bank was offered a role at another commercial bank, but used this purely as a bargaining tool to clinch a better package at an investment bank where he was also interviewing. This back fired. After moving into investment banking, he discovering that investment banking wasn't for him, he quit after just three months and has been unemployed for almost 10 months, despite having skills which are highly desirable.

His original recruiter says the candidate's life is now pretty tough. "He's sent his CV to all the banks and has worked with too many recruiters. It hasn't reflected well on him.

"When candidates manipulate offers in this way, it just shows that they don't value the firm. Banks aren't very forgiving, they have a blacklist of candidates who do this, and so do recruiters," she adds.

The greedy fantasist

Shawn Yu, consultant, financial services, Robert Walters, knows a candidate who demanded a base salary twice his current one for a strategy position in a commercial bank.

"The candidate's salary expectations were unrealistically high," says Yu. He turned down the original offer and instead took a role outside banking, only to later realise he wasn't cut out for it either.

We would like to encourage you to share your stories about strange candidates below.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORShree Ann Mathavan Insider Comment
  • So
    Sophia
    13 July 2011

    @Hipster- why send the guy to a firm he already worked for? or was it a case of him re-vamping his CV????

  • El
    Elite
    8 July 2011

    issue is, times are bloody hard right now. its ok for those who have cosy jobs with an income but when you are out of a job for a while, its eats away at you day by day. Im not saying lying is ok, but when you have no income coming in from any where and you are stuck like s***, any thing goes. Negativity takes over, not just mentally but emotionally. you cling on to any bit of hope that you will be employable once again and be part of the crowd who are squashed like sardines on the train (8am??), etc. you try anything just to be part of the working crowd again.

  • Pr
    Pravda
    7 July 2011

    I had a good one a few years ago when I was working in investment banking: after relatively hard negotiations (on salary and joining date) we hired an analyst from another bank. Before she actually joined the firm, she called us to explain that she felt very sorry for having lied to us: she had been fired from the other bank two months ago (therefore she was not going to receive the fantastic bonus she was demanding us to cover) and the late joining date was not a gardening leave or similar but some vacations with friends she had already paid for. It is obvious she never joined our firm. Amazingly she never thought we were going to withdraw the offer. The sad thing is that our hiring decision would not have changed too much, maybe her salary would have been lower and for sure she would have missed those vacations ...

  • Hi
    Hipster
    6 July 2011

    13 years ago I was a recruiter at Rob Walters. This is in the day before you could check someone out on the net within 5 mins.
    I interviewed a relatively senior Compliance candidate who - whilst having some odd personal aspects ...like the poor quality ginger toupe he wore and his CV photo (which is something you should never, ever do unless you are super hot and female) was taken on the steps of a stately home with the toupe at a rakish angle. I sent this candidate down to a Japanese bank for an interview. 60 mins later I got a call saying thank you for the candidate, we will not be taking it further as we actually fired this guy a year ago for gross misconduct and all he appears to have done since then is start to wear a ginger wig and change his name. I felt very sorry for this guy as it was clear he was desperate for an income so instead of calling him I asked him to meet me which I thought was a little kinder - I told him that we had an issue with the client feedback and told him what it was. He froze, there was an icy pause of around 2 mins - then he get up and left without a word ...somehow maintaining his dignity whilst still sporting the rug. I still feel sorry the guy

  • Mi
    Mike
    6 July 2011

    if she is not interested in investment banking and offered to quit after three months then why she is applying to all banks???

    if her skills are desirable then why you guys are not taking advantage by recruiting her at a deep discount salary/wages???

    many contradictions in the same article.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.