Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

FRED BAYR: Three substantial steps to a happier relationship between recruiters and candidates

If the barrage of antagonistic and defensive comments typically posted on the bottom of these articles is anything to go by, the relationship between the average recruiter and the average candidate is not in a healthy state.

Some candidates are, admittedly, excessively disparaging. Recruiters are not 'scum' (at least not many of them); we are just doing our jobs. On the other hand, however, we recruiters are also inordinately defensive; we view criticism with more spite than Al Fayed has for Chelsea fans.

As the parents in the recruiter-candidate relationship, it's up to us recruiters to take this in hand. There is a way to heal this rift and it involves the three point plan below. If this is followed by everyone in the recruitment industry, recruiters and candidates will coexist harmoniously. At least I like to think so.

1) Total and utter honesty

Recruiters must be honest. We must appreciate that candidates are human beings and not mere numbers on a database. We must not make promises that undermine candidates' trust. We must never send out CVs without permission. In no circumstances must we divulge how much someone earns to their colleagues.

2) Acceptance of disinterest

Candidates have real jobs with real responsibilities. Sometimes they have to blow us recruiters out. Occasionally, candidates might even agree to turn up for a meeting simply to get us off the phone. Unfortunately, this is something we need to accept.

Recruiters must be humble. We must learn to take no for an answer. When a candidate says he or she will turn up for a meeting and doesn't, we must accept this, stoically. Under no circumstances must we spread rumours about them across the City as a means of revenge.

3) Nullification of arrogance

Being a recruiter is frustrating. Some candidates are simply not particularly bright. Some are less bright than we are. However, this doesn't give us the right to feel intellectually superior. Personally, I have a third class degree in English Literature from the University of Winchester and am fully accepting of my place in the hierarchy. However, even if I come across someone with a BA in Hospitality Management, I am never rude or overbearing.

It does not take much. This is my manifesto for change. One day, the relationship between candidates and recruiters shall be a happy one. And I, Fred Bayr, am leading the way.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORFred Bayr Insider Comment
  • Do
    Does it matter?
    4 June 2011

    1) Recruiters are largely people with zero integrity and have no respect for candidates. They do not give honest feedback, dont even reply to attempts to contact them. I will never employ recruiters to hire staff, simple runs too high a risk of getting the wrong people.

    2) This is really just BS. Some of the top most recruiting firms (You name it, most of them are on this website) badmouth candidates when they try hard without requisite qualifications Finance is a role that being an Ivy and having MBA just means little to the performance you can generate. Recruiters are being paid to hire crappy people. This system will fail again in time to come.

    3) Most candidates will be far brighter than the recruiters especially if you are in efinancials. The fact is recruiters think they have an edge over the candidate which tilts the bargaining power, they can afford to be arrogant, handle candidates sloppily and delete emails WITHOUT READING THEM. Even as a fund manager, there is a courtesy to read things sent to them before its sent to the bin. So much for work ethics.

  • Gr
    Grammar Teacher
    11 April 2011

    @ GG - Monkey, why don't you learn how to spell correctly?

  • DJ
    DJ
    11 April 2011

    @GG - just revisited this article to see if you would be sad enough to respond to my comment and yes, you didn't fail to disappoint. You claim that you are neither a recruiter or a failed banker - well I am delighted for you. Your comments don't wind the likes of myself up - they just makes me feel sad that morons such as yourself still exist. So my advise to you is to stop showing your ignorance and lack of education by writing pathetic comments that have no relevance to what is being discussed. Now run along like a good little boy!

  • GG
    GG
    11 April 2011

    @ DJ - thankfully I am not a recruiter or a failed banker - I actually just find it extremely amusing wind up thickos like you.

  • Su
    Successful Banker
    11 April 2011

    I disagree with those who call recruiters morons, idiots and so forth. They are none of those, they are simply the working class of the financial services industry. Working class people are rarely famous for their manners or intellectual capacity. But we need them to do the dirty job of recruitment for us.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.