Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

The best recruiters grow with their candidates; unfortunately, this happens rarely

After more interesting things have been taken out of the equation it's everyone's favourite fantasy: a recruiter who works with you throughout your career, who'll guide you from the darkest days of spreadsheet hell through to the joys of senior management, who knows what you want, and who won't dump you in a business run by an inadequate bully with pretensions to megalomania.

They do exist.

One of them is John Axworthy, head of the investment banking practice at Odgers Berndtson. "I've been placing corporate financiers for 17 years," says Axworthy. "There are people I placed in their first slot as newly qualified accountants and who I've more recently placed in positions running businesses."

However, finding a recruiter-turned-headhunter whose career progresses in line with yours is getting harder to do. Recruiters are switching sectors and falling by the wayside more frequently than they used to.

"If you stick to your market, you grow with your candidates," says another headhunter. "Unfortunately, market conditions have forced me to adapt and to move into new areas. I've done everything from M&A to structured credit and haven't had the consistency that allows you to work with one set of people."

As banks do their very best to fill junior positions in-house, recruiters are also being locked out of junior roles, preventing them from forming relationships with entry-level candidates.

Some headhunters overcome this by making time for associates even though they only place people at the senior end. "I often give advice to talented juniors," says Axworthy. "If an associate at a top investment bank sends me their CV, I will always meet them. It's important to identify the new blood that's coming through."

Rather than finding a single person to nurture you for 20 years as they themselves progress from contingency recruiter to fully-fledged-senior-search-professional, there may, therefore, be an alternative: start cultivating relationships with existing senior headhunters as early as you possibly can.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • Ro
    RobIFARecruit
    26 August 2010

    @Ben and @Lohn, I agree with HH26, you must be poor at what you do as you seem to be judging us on your own pooor standards, my clients and candidates alike get a first class service, I have worked in the same sector for 6 years and have no intention of moving into another therefore I have dealt with my clients and candidates over the same amount of years

  • HH
    HH
    26 July 2010

    @Ben and @Lohn; seems like you both are terrible candidates, and thus dont get calls from recruiters!

  • Lo
    Lohn
    16 July 2010

    Best recruiters??? There are only bad recruiters, worse recruiter and worst recruiters.

  • Be
    Ben
    16 July 2010

    No such thing as a good recruiter- ALL recruiters are a waste of space. They are pointless and offer no value.

  • na
    nauman1
    16 July 2010

    It is no surprise that recruiters get a bad name and this is because a lot of them do a bad job, especially from a candidate's perspective. Generalising everyone to be like this would be incorrect. There are certainly some good recruiters out there. However, it does appears that a growing number seem to be motivated by commission income and commission income only. My recent experience has been that a lot of agents are not too bothered about meeting, even when offered. They would rather get you're application forward as soon as possible for any job moderately relevant. Maybe it's the pressures of the market, but then why is not everyone in a hurry?

    I fully understand that it is clients who pay the fee and not the candidates. However, the more astute recruiters know that it is the candidates who actually bring in the money and success (as a candidate now and later perhaps as a client) and establishing a relationship does pay off in the long term.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.