Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

GUEST COMMENT: The football is a warning of what could happen to the City if immigration quotas are introduced

Bowing to pressure from the BNPs' favourite newspaper, The Daily Mail, the coalition is corroding the City's ability to hire the people we need. Immigration quotas are about the best way of damaging the economy I can think of. Forget terrorism, tax and the crap transport system.

London is often compared to tennis at Wimbledon, biggest tournament in the world, but with many non-Brits; would anyone bother to watch if we had a quota of British players? Do you know who is the British number 20? Would you pay 200 quid to watch him play our number 50?

Alternatively, think of the City in terms of football. Once English football is stripped of its overseas premier league players, it's not that great is it? English premier teams are multinational and feared, the English FA is English and a joke.

I go to meetings in London where I'm the only person born here, but in Paris or Frankfurt I more rarely meet non-nationals. That is why Europe has four financial centres - the City, Canary Wharf, Mayfair and Edinburgh. We hire the best people; a bank in Paris hires the best Frenchman. That's why we're top and they're not.

To say the City is important to the UK is a big understatement, ask yourself where Britain would get money if not for finance? Maybe making cars? Steel? Organic courgettes, hand made souvenirs for tourists?

A huge chunk of the most useful people working in the City are yanks. Maybe Mail readers don't know this, but the USA isn't in the EU. Britain is putting up taxes, and when faced with immigration caps too, many of the people we want will stay at home or go somewhere better. Some will be important enough that not only will they not contribute to business units in London, the group will be moved with them.

The non-EU people banks import aren't benefit scroungers. They aren't looking for free treatment on the NHS. May of them will contribute more than 60% of their income in tax and pay for private healthcare and schooling. They are helping to reduce our financial problems, whilst getting precious little from the government in return.

We will hear high handed nonsense about how the system will be 'selective', but anyone who has ever dealt with the formless chaos in the Borders Agency knows otherwise.

Quotas aren't racist, they're stupid. The days when the City was wholly run by white 'chaps' like me are gone, and we are the richer for it, but if we damage our competitiveness we are in deep trouble as a country.

Dominic Connor is a quant headhunter for P&D Quantiative Recruitment

author-card-avatar
AUTHORDominic Connor Insider Comment
  • L.
    L. Boychuk
    15 July 2010

    Funny, funny, funny... neither work nor live in UK, visited twice as tourist.

    As long as you hesitate to punish people who break your immigration law and be as racist as you are (read your comments in this thread) less people with bright minds will want to move to other country as yours to work for your prosperity filling unwelcome and rejected.

  • Bo
    Bond
    1 July 2010

    May I point out that many, if not most, of the large financial institutions in the City are actually not British companies. So while you are at it, why not introduce quota for foreign companies as well?

    How many English people are employed by American, Japanese or other foreign banks? As far as I know, these banks don't display signs saying 'Daily Mail Readers Not Allowed In'.

    I am all for tightening entry criteria as long as they are based on skill and what the person can bring to this country rather than them being from the EU or not.

    During and after a recession, it is easy to think if you are unemployed that you should have priority over foreigners (many of whom also lost their jobs and went back home by the way).

    ...

  • Bo
    Bond
    1 July 2010

    ...

    Unfortunately, we quickly forget that the main reason there were so many jobs in the City for us Brits in the first place is that London is seen as a global financial hub with international companies and highly skilled workers. If it weren't for this international position, the number of finance jobs in London would certainly have not been anywhere near the current or past levels.

    Look at Paris (the biggest financial centre in... France), how many banks are based there? Jobs go mostly to the locals but how many financial jobs are there in the first place?

    I don't think that the government is stupid enough to drive us in that direction. They're just trying to make the right noises to please some of the Daily Mail Reader's friends but they will make sure highly skilled workers who can contribute positively to our economy are always welcome. Or at least I hope so..

  • Ba
    Ban Cap
    29 June 2010

    I am sure after the cap, FA would look for a local for English Football coaching job. I wonder in what direction the English football will go considering they did not find any suitable for such role in last 5 years.

  • PF
    PF
    29 June 2010

    To :Daily Mail Reader

    Spot on! I am certainly not a Daily Mail Reader but I could not agree more with every single word you have written. And I am pretty sure that is what most of the people of this country think too. I will add that the self important, arrogant and mostly inefficient employers and recruitment agencies should be fined heavily for not recruiting and/or training people bred and/or educated here. Only very exceptional people should be brought in to work here from abroad.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.