Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

CONFESSIONS OF A SERIAL INTERVIEWEE: Follow this interview advice, and you WILL get a job on the buyside

The advice below is a distillation of the wisdom gathered from the many occasions when I've been either interviewer or interviewee. Needless to say, not all of my interviews have worked out, but that doesn't mean I'm not an expert. After all, I'm working - on the buyside - in Mayfair.

The non-verbals

1) Seriousness about the job

PASS: Sharp dressing, arrive early, good handshake (not a kiss). Phone is on silent.

FAIL: Taking calls, checking your Crackberry. Dressing inappropriately. Arriving late, get your 4 from TFL if your train was delayed, don't make it my problem.

Bottom line: If you can't even pretend for the duration of the interview, are you willing to give it 150% all week long? Do not underestimate the first impression. One intern interviewee may as well have worn a bikini; instant FAIL.

2) Engagement with the interviewer?

PASS: Do you ask questions and want to know more about the company? Can you handle the mandatory British "How was your journey from....? / My, what interesting weather we are having!" as well as the more technical questions?

FAIL: Short, sharp answers. This is not a spelling bee... If all I was looking for was answers, I'd Google them. And no pre-rehearsed current affairs commentaries that you deem relevant. This isn't Radio 4.

Bottom line: Can you communicate within our team? Are you safe to unleash on clients?

3) Focus and body language

PASS: Use your body language to mirror mine. Lean forward; maintain eye contact; don't cross your arms and legs. Focus on ME.

FAIL: Avoiding eye contact, getting distracted by other things. The same can be said for candidates who waffle and lose their own train of thought.

Bottom line: I always look at body language. I will also deliberately interview in a busy shared lounge at our offices to see the focus of the candidates. I even made the more senior candidates take a three hour modelling test on a laptop while a conference went on around them. In case you have forgotten, this is SPARTA...

The verbals

They may not be structured this simply, but these are the questions you will always get asked. If you don't know how to answer them you might as well become an accountant.

4) Tell me about yourself

PASS: Let the interviewer structure this, put it back to them. Don't assume they want a blow by blow chronological account about your life from the moment you learned to walk.

FAIL: A blow by blow chronological account about your life from the moment you learned to walk. Failing that, a linear regurgitation of your CV.

Bottom line: Build rapport, try to find some common ground. "A pity I hate football...."

5) What would you do if faced with.... An impossible question?

PASS: I want to see how you think. So, explain your thought process and all the unknowns, until you arrive at the answer. Be prepared to defend it. If I tell you that's wrong, think it through and reconsider. Get the interviewer involved, don't be afraid to ask questions.

FAIL: Giving the answer without talking through the process - I was never looking for an: a, b, c (all of the above) answer. Switching off when told that you are wrong. Do not pass Go, do not collect 200, go straight back to the Job board.

Bottom line: I will always have given this thought myself. I am impressed when candidates come up with things I've missed. But the most important thing is if they aren't thrown by being told they're wrong / stopped mid-sentence. No sulking please! There will be situations where opinions vary and someone will pull rank. Show that you can handle it.

6) What do you know about the company/role?

PASS: Be able to make intelligent comment. Or ideally have some focussed questions.

FAIL: If you don't even know the little that is on the website...

Bottom line: Are you resourceful? There are seldom "cut and paste" solutions to daily problems.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORAnonymous Insider Comment
  • Bi
    BigP
    17 March 2010

    @Davros... he didn't say if they were male or female!!!!

  • Be
    Ben Akroyd
    17 March 2010

    Yes, planning for CFA works fine. Frankly, I got my current job as PM partly because the HR girl had that on her check list. In reality, my boss does not appreciate me spending time on my CFA. Even refused a few precious extra days off for the dreadful Level II exam. No need anyhow in my job as I know about everything anyway from University. And who wants to know all this silly crap on CDOs etc with which all those CFA charterholders contributed a good deal to the credit crisis.
    In conclusion, this exam is overrated by HR people and somewhat underrated on the work floor (only if u hadn't had a proper university degree in Finance/Economics.

  • Da
    David
    16 March 2010

    this fake approach, of not telling who you really are and what you really want, has brought us and the entire indistry to this crisis... OK you fake the interview and get the job, OK you pretend to be someone else for a week, a month and then what? frustration and anger accumulate and then one day you get up and shoot the entire trading floor. You cant walk through life like this... yes you should be civilized, cultured and so on, but these things should be natural. I always tell the trainees we hire - try to understand what your core competence is and then develop it. It could take you years to understand what your core competence is, but there is no other way.

  • st
    steve
    16 March 2010

    As an interviewer, this guy is going to finish up with sycophants and goody goodies with no creativity whatsoever. He is far too rigid in what he expects from a candidate, and far too sure that he knows all the answers. If I was his employer I would get someone else with a bit more flexibility and emotional intelligence to interview people, and demote this guy.

  • Da
    Davros
    16 March 2010

    "One intern interviewee may as well have worn a bikini; instant FAIL. "

    Bikini = instant WIN

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.