Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Observations on why living standards are grossly lower in London than NY

Megan McArdle doesn't have a long history in banking. According to her biography she spent a mere summer as an associate in an investment bank before becoming a writer for the Economist and a blogger.

She does, however, have an MBA (and therefore could possibly have been a banker) and interesting views on why the standard of living in London is so bad.

According to McArdle, her time in London revealed to her that, "the standard of living in any given profession is lower [than in the US]." Specifically, she says this was manifested in:

1) Horrible housing:

People in London live in smaller houses that are hotter in summer and colder in winter than houses in the US.

2) Horrible commuting:

People in London have longer and more expensive commutes than people in the US.

3) Horrible behaviour:

McArdle observed non-poor people in Europe doing stuff that only poor people would contemplate doing in the US. This included bringing packed lunches to work; hanging washing on the line; not having cable TV.

"I don't want to sound as if I'm saying Britain's a terrible place--it's lovely, and I miss it," says McArdle. "But the amount that people are able to consume is much less than the amount Americans are able to consume, and many of the things they forego make real difference in things like personal comfort."

Above average earners in banking may be able to avoid horrors such as hanging out the washing, but McArdle's observations remain interesting, particularly as Obama's slamming of banks in the US has helped raise hopes for London's future as a financial centre.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • an
    andrew1234
    18 January 2010

    I live in London but really enjoy the states and new york. Some of the observations are incorrect though.
    Rent in manhatton is way higher than London and many of the flats are awful in new york.
    You can always get a cheap meal in nyc, especially china town which is great, but the tipping culture of 20% plus makes things actually very expensive on the whole.
    All city types are rude and agressive, Brits tend to be a bit more conservative though.
    In the end I'd rather not be in either city if career allowed it!

  • Ha
    Happy_in_Oz
    18 January 2010

    While you guys argue whether it is better to be in NY or London...I am having a fantastic life as a banker in Sydney. Quality of living is one of the highest in the world. Spent my weekend catching some great waves at 3 different beaches. Only 5 minutes to walk to Bondi Beach and 15 to Tamarama Beach. Fantastic cuisine with some of the best seafood in the world. And the money on my level is better than US (not sure about London), especially with the strong A$ rate. Tax system is pretty lenient (Under Living away from home allowance - LAFHA - rent is paid out on a tax free basis to expats). Great healthcare infrastructure, where Medicare covers most of healthcare related costs. And the exposure you get as a banker in the Real Estate (high amount of highly active REITs), Infrastructure (Australia has always been a centre of excellence in this field as a result of larrge amount of PPP/PFIs and listed Infrastructure pure-plays) or Resources (no explanation needed) sectors is one of the best in the world, despite the relatilvey small size of the economy. And the best thing - the Australians I have met in my two years are really laid back and pragmatic about work. The work to live....

  • Ha
    Hammersmith1962
    18 January 2010

    Both Cities (NY and London) have become zombified with political correctness, chaviness and South Asian yuppifies. Both Cities are dreadful.

  • li
    littleenglander
    18 January 2010

    @johnrobert

    "obese ignorant bigoted gun-carrying bible-bashing radical retards"

  • jo
    johnrobert
    17 January 2010

    People seem to be making a massive error between Manhattan and New York City. Are we speaking of the relative differences between SW3, SW3, Regent's Park, Knightsbridge and Manhattan? If we take London and New York as cities there is little similarity between the two so any argument is fairly fruitless. New York as a city cannot compare to London in terms of museums, theatres ( I do not mean how many Lion King equivalents there are), concerts etc. As for the authors comments regarding standard of living, you shouldn't see Queens being different from SE London. We cannot honestly comment on the author's comments without know what "New York City" she is speaking of. So many people from both Europe and America think of New York as being the island of Manhattan. I would rather live in the SE of the UK, with relatively thin, relatively educated people than in New York (read Manhattan) surrounded by obese ignorant bigoted gun-carrying bible-bashing radical retards.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.