Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

OUT OF LEHMAN: Quitting your job to do an MBA may be the worst career move ever

Are you in a job and going nowhere? Consider yourself lucky. Quitting a job to do an MBA in the current market, particularly one of the accelerated MBA programmes which the Wall Street Journal appears so keen on, is a very stupid thing to do.

While you will learn new skills, and graduate with a better chance of being recruited, the MBA is an expensive and intense experience. Before you take the plunge think carefully whether your already beaten-down morale can handle the worst case scenario - graduating jobless and heavily in debt.

A good friend of mine used to work as a product manager in a FMCG company. Frustrated with her job, she applied and got admitted in one of Europe's Top 3 business schools. She quit her company and joined the program in Sep 2008. She graduated last month and her timing couldn't have been worse. Her ex-employer has a hiring freeze; recruitment on campus was down to a trickle and her hopes of becoming a management consultant are all but over.

Even when the times were good, landing a career triple jump (switching industry, role and location) was tricky. In this job market recruiters are less inclined to take the leap of faith. If you are keen to switch careers, make sure you put in a long internship stint - it will do wonders to your chances of landing a full time offer.

In times like these, therefore, if an MBA makes sense at all, a two year MBA programme will be best. It may be more expensive, but unless you are really good at predicting when the economy will recover, in which case you case you stand to gain much more by investing in the markets, the two year program will give you a little more time to find that right job. Opportunity cost is still low (compared to the boom years) and the summer internship will give you the chance to test your career preferences.

A two year MBA will also give you more time to network. A 100-hour work week in the accelerated program doesn't leave you with much time to socialize. The two year program gives you the time to build a strong network of friends to lean on when the times are bad. In the last eight months, I have switched two jobs. The leads for both came through my business school classmates.

Think wisely and don't be in a hurry. An MBA is not necessarily the key to a six figure income and life at the top of the executive food chain. In the worst case scenario, it may simply leave you shackled with debt.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORAnonymous Insider Comment
  • Ni
    Nim
    28 October 2009

    Your friend graduated from Insead or IE and couldnt get a job in Mgmt Consulting? How bad are the markets? lol... I myself have attended several consulting firm presentations in the last few weeks - and I know they are hiring.

    100 hour weeks? Are you kidding me? I find that figure rather hard to believe...

  • Ni
    Nim
    28 October 2009

    Your friend graduated from Insead of IE and couldnt get a job in Mgmt Consulting? How bad are the markets? lol... I myself have attended several consulting firm presentations in the last few weeks - and I know they are hiring.

    100 hour weeks? Are you kidding me? I find that figure rather hard to believe...

  • MP
    MP
    28 October 2009

    Dude, the MBA is the biggest joke in Management Education and a pure money spinner for Business Schools. Wanna learn about business, go invest USD 100K and start a business...you'll learn much more, network aggressively and plus may even generate a nice return on your investment!!!..

  • ce
    ceydamete
    28 October 2009

    i agree too, its all a joke

  • Af
    A fan
    27 October 2009

    coming out of a 2 year program now is just as bad as coming out of a 1 year program (-: plus the extra expenses, and there's no such thing as a zero opportunity cost for an extra year of being in school. Don't believe whoever tells you one can network more or less in 1 year vs 2 - it's up to the person and depends on the culture of the school as well.
    An inseader, who did the 'triple jump' as your author here calls it in 2003, not a great year for coming out of b-school either. A year down the line 90% of my classmates were arguably better off or in any case no worse than without th. MBA, and we had the time of our lives as a bonus...

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.