Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

When will this posturing around bonuses translate into action?

With Hector Sants last week saying any obligation to curb City bonuses should lie with the government rather than the regulator, it's taken Alistair Darling a while to respond. However, now he's hinted at a relatively hardline approach, but it's debatable whether this will actually translate into imminent action.

Speaking to the Sunday Times, the chancellor said: "If we need to change the law and toughen things up, we can do that. I'm quite clear that some of the problems we have today were caused by the fact that some traders were incentivised to take risks which neither they nor their bosses fully understood."

He adds that the FSA code, which has largely been seen as something of a backtrack from the regulator's original stance, is only "part of our approach".

Barclays has also shown that guarantees are still on the agenda, with the Telegraph reporting on Saturday that it's offered 30m to lure five commodities traders from JPMorgan. This is likely to further fan the flames of public anger, particularly after the news last week that RBS is also paying guarantees.

Still, while it's easy to view Darling's words as a pledge for legislation on banking bonuses, it seems more like an attempt to placate the public in the face of a rising tide of anti-banker sentiment.

After all, he doesn't actually say he's going to make these changes, rather that the government "could", which in itself is going to generate headlines before any decisions have been made.

The FSA's watered down remuneration report was still seen as the regulator going out on a limb compared to its contemporaries elsewhere in the world and the government would be foolish to pass draconian regulations before any other major financial centre.

The whole point of the FSA adjusting its original proposals was that any 'prescriptive' restrictions would mean top talent simply exits the UK for another financial centre.

Obviously, the government still awaiting the results of Sir David Walker's review into whether there's a case for capping bonuses before taking action.

But any serious changes will have to be implemented in a globally coordinated way, and concrete legislative decisions are unlikely to be committed to until after the G20 summit of world leaders in September.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORPaul Clarke
  • em
    emilio13
    18 August 2009

    @sasha

    Will never happen but fun to watch all the posturing.
    Fact: Joe Public has no clue about the inner workings of the IB's etc so when the Sun/Daily Mirror and the like run negative headlines, Joe Public leaps on it as justification to hang all bankers per bank bailouts etc. At least Hester has recently had the balls to say it like it is. The Gvmnt needs to be repaid so the quickest way to do this is to get the best talent onboard to generate profit. Fact the best talent costs money so you do the match and explain that to the braying mob.

  • po
    polverino
    17 August 2009

    @sasha

    no chance mate!

  • Sa
    Sasha
    17 August 2009

    It's in the interest of the public, the taxpayers, and, in particular, the bankers, to now have polverino's contract published.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.