Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

No staff, no compromise

Banks are busting guts trying to hire enough people. Does this mean they're prepared to be a teeny bit flexible about what they want? No.

The most recent trusty survey from recruitment firm Morgan McKinley suggests there are now a full 1,000 more jobs than candidates in the London financial services market.

Recruiters trying to fill those 1,000 empty posts are definitely feeling the pain. "There's a shortage of people," says Andrew Chancellor, head of financial services hiring at rival recruiter Robert Walters, "Some jobs have been open for 12 months or more."

But rather than making a slight exception and giving an eager outsider a chance, it seems banks are resolutely sticking to their guns and insisting on hiring people who precisely fit their job descriptions - or not hiring at all.

"There's a shortage of candidates with five years' deal experience - there are just not that many of them on the market," says Andrew Lynch, a consultant at Akamai Financial. "But most banks are looking for people of a similar calibre to existing staff - these are client-facing and highly technical roles and they just can't risk lowering the standard."

The only whiff of flexibility comes from third-tier banks in areas like corporate finance - James Heath of recruitment firm Greenwich Partners says some lesser-known organisations are having to "look outside their Utopian ideal" and are now willing to hire auditors.

Thousands of applications

But if third tier institutions are being forced to scrape about for candidates, more desirable destinations have no such problem. According to US publication Deal Journal, US hedge fund Cerberus Capital Management interviewed 2,500 candidates for just 110 jobs last year. Similarly, US boutique Greenhill received 2,000 applications for ....eight places on its UK graduate programme.

So what can you do if you don't want to work for a third-tier house and your CV doesn't include three years' experience at a bulge-bracket? One option may be to send your CV straight to banks' own recruiters, who are less likely to insist on ticking all the boxes than recruitment firms. "If they're using a headhunter, they're not going to lower the bar," says Lynch.

Alternatively, you can always accept defeat: even if you do get in, there's no guarantee you'll stay there. "In the last boom, banks took on anyone for the sake of it," says Chancellor. "When the markets went down all those people got thrown out."

author-card-avatar
AUTHORAnonymous Insider Comment
  • Al
    Alex
    27 June 2007

    if your are a senior financial manager in another industry than banking and investment with a past (before 2000) experience in asset management, what would it cost to get back to the banking, investment or cf? or is it completely impossible giving this article?

  • An
    Anonymous
    27 June 2007

    Isn't it odd that James Heath of Greenwich Partners is now saying that things have got so bad that "lesser-known organisations are having to look outside their Utopian ideal and are now willing to hire auditors" for corporate finance roles?

    He was quite happy to give a two part 'guest comment' about how auditors can relatively easily make the transition from practice to Front Office roles!

    Any alterior motives James?

  • ad
    adetunji raheem
    27 June 2007

    i wonder why this gut, they may need to look beyond the shore of europe and america to recruit staffers...i beleive they can gain more from recruiting from africa.... We have lots of experience hand in any field of banking, accounting, investment and retail and marketing in Nigeria that are willing to change job.....try and make the application open to africa , you may find your best bet here

  • PJ
    P J Barron
    27 June 2007

    It's laughable hearing senior people in banking talk about the need for their organisation to change & how they are looking to bring in new ideas etc. How often have the experience & capabilities of a candidate been a strong match for a particular banking role but they then lose out to a less qualified candidate from a direct competitor bank!

    Do what you always do & get what you always get.

    PJ Barron

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.