Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Letting rip against recruiters

Our article about nefarious recruitment practices provoked a tirade of responses. Didn't get a chance to read it last time? Here it is again, with another chance to have your say.

With hiring buoyant and candidates scarce, recruiters might be expected to be incomparably charming in their efforts to woo finance professionals. Not necessarily, it seems.

An email exchange between a Tim Seymour of recruiter Seymour Chase and James Kennedy of recruitment firm Robert Half reveals the less salubrious side of the recruitment industry.

Seymour, a recruiter of recruiters, attempted to solicit Kennedy for a role with a 'niche recruitment firm'. But rather than cajoling his target by telephone, Seymour's first approach took the form of a mass email - which was visibly sent to around 40 other candidates.

And when Kennedy objected to Seymour's technique? Instead of apologising, Seymour emailed back to say, "Couldn't care less mate. You tw*t."

Rudeness isn't the only foible of insalubrious recruitment firms. Others include despatching CVs without their owners' permission, never responding to job applications, and advertising jobs that don't actually exist.

How common are these faults? You tell us. Kennedy maintains they're not common at all: "I get called by recruiters a lot and this is the first time I've encountered this kind of thing."

The recruitment industry is unregulated. As a result, unprofessional conduct is punishable only by market forces - the hope being that candidates and clients alike will give nefarious firms a wide berth. This may already be happening in Seymour's case: a call to his Birmingham number reveals he's out of the office - perhaps permanently.

Have you ever had a bad experience with a recruitment firm? Add your comment and let us know.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • re
    recruitmentrogue
    25 April 2008

    please do not tar us all with the same brush! I am the first to admit that there are elements of our industry that are bad, treatment of candidates, lack of responses, CV going out without authorisation. But is every other industry so squeaky clean? I guess it is easy to pick an easy target. I must admit that this is not common practice if you choose your recruitment company carefully. It amazes me amount of people who i meet with who have met with other agencies and when i ask out of courtesy to make sure that anyone i put them forward to does not overlap with anyone else they may be talking with, I would say that 1 in 4 candidates have no real idea where their CV is going, ''it may have gone there, or, I think the other recuitment company may have sent it there'' get a grip, grow some balls and control the process. This is in no way an excuse for the agent to flyer the CV. Regulation!?! for what - where we get our jobs from? In the greater scheme of things who really cares where our jobs come from? regulating the industry would be a complete waste of time - any other industry's regulated because the reprocussions of it not being could be huge - but recruitment, come on..

  • K-
    K-my
    25 April 2008

    I think recruiters are as bad as real estate agents. From personal experience, i have not been impressed by any of the two....

    It is an extra layer of mostly dead wood and used car sales men that will not even talk to you if you don't check all the boxes they require...Majority doesn't even wanna meet you and they try to sell you for a role...absolutely ridiculous...

  • Ma
    Martin Joyce
    6 December 2007

    Buttocks, hmmm.

  • jo
    john
    18 September 2007

    I regularly got about 3 to 5 emails a day.. that adds up over a year.. I remembered the agencies and the consultants... Needless to say when I needed something from them (by the way i replied)... as in a job.. if it was not resultant in a cut for them .. silence.. .. I will not go into the fact that this will be remembered and I would rather not use an agency. A good manager knows how to recruit and does not need them.. the sooner the industry wakes up to this applying for a job would be a more rewarding experience.

  • Ke
    Ken
    30 June 2007

    Oh how glad i am to find this article and everyones comments.

    I have been a bit depressed lately with the way my agencies have treated me and i just realised that i am not alone. It's really shocking that other people have faced the same problems as me. This is a real emmotional tourcher.

    I have been sent to 7 interviews via agencies and promised a phone call with 24 hours. All i have wanted is feedback on how i did so atleast i could improve myself in the future. They are so nice and helpful before u go for ur interview but if u didnt do well they couldnt care less. They are really ruthless and to think all the money and effort i spent in travelling and preparation for my interviews and they cant spare 2 mins to give me feedback.

    Its horrible and shocking...

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.