Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Have your say: capping bonuses

In case you missed it, here's our earlier article on the notion that fringe elements of the Labour Party want to limit the size of bonuses. "Bad plan", has been the unanimous response so far.

There are claims the Government is contemplating a limit to City workers' earning potential.

The move (intimated in The Times ) follows a slew of disparaging comments on 'obscene' bonuses at the Labour Party conference.

Representatives of the Square Mile's best interests are rushing to man the barricades. One City insider tells us: "If they do this, you'll be left with a huge hole in the centre of London which used to be called the financial services industry."

Deprived of mega-bonuses, Michael Snyder, policy chairman of the City of London, suggests bankers would go elsewhere. "The City of London is the world's leading international financial centre and to keep that primacy it has to attract the world's best talent," he says. "Firms pay what is required to secure that talent - and their shareholders demand it."

And what if bonuses were capped? Banks could take a lead from retailer John Lewis, which has a decree that none of its executives can earn more than 25 times the income of the lowest-paid employee living in London with four children.

Given banks' notorious frugality when it comes to paying cleaning staff, this would put bonuses at roughly 250,000 and no more.

Should bonuses be capped? - Add your comment and let us know what you think.

We will add your comment or question below and keep it anonymous unless you tell us otherwise.

author-card-avatar
AUTHORAnonymous Insider Comment
  • Mi
    Mikhail
    25 October 2006

    This would damage to the competitive advantage of London compared to other European cities that was created by deregulation and internationalisation over the last 25 years. London City attracts the best talent in Europe with its higher compensation.
    I do not believe that the Labour party is seriously intending to
    introduce such kind of legislation. However, should such a cap see the light of day, it will undermine the service economy of the UK and will decrease the standard of living of precisely those who are upset by the obscenity of bonuses in the banks.

  • Eg
    Egor
    21 October 2006

    "a huge hole in the centre of London which used to be called the financial services industry" is about right. Why would anybody have that kind of life if not for (at least a prospect) of serious money (defined here as upwards of 7 figures/yr)?

    The extortionate 40% marginal income tax rate is only bearable if the sums it is computed on are appropriately large - otherwise, there's always other cities. Any quant or trader worth their salt can relocate pretty much whenever they want (finance professionals being one of the most globally mobile population groups I'd say), so I'd say 90% of the good ones will have left within months of such legislation passing.

  • Ma
    Mark
    20 October 2006

    At last the Labour party shrug off their centrist clothing & reveal their true Trotskyite selves. If a company thinks an employee is worth it and the bonuses represent a percentage of revenue raised by an individual then what business is it of the Government? CEO pay is another thing because they often control the apparatus used to decide financial remuneration whereas most City bonuses are decided by committees or much more senior people with comparable information from various sources.
    Start selling you large London houses, this would mean the end of the housing
    market as well as the Financial markets. See you in New York!

    Regards
    Mark Curtis

  • Jo
    John
    18 October 2006

    The government should be pleased.

    There's corporation tax paid by the company, income tax at 40% paid by the individual and 12.8% national insurance by the employer. The Chancellor gets a windfall at bonus time and should be celebrating.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.