Headhunters advise ING staff to stay calm
Ever since the Dutch bank declared it was "reviewing the future positioning of its investment banking activities" last Sunday, the future has looked uncertain. But reaching immediately for the telephone may not be the answer.
Gary Goldstein, chairman of the Whitney Group in the US, advises: "Sit tight and consider your options. Panic can lead to big mistakes." In London, a headhunter that has received calls from skittish ING staff counsels: "People that are on the telephone now won't get very good terms because they look desperate."
ING's plans for investment banking appear to have foundered over the high salaries demanded by investment bankers. At a press conference last week, Kees Maas, chief financial officer at ING, said the bank accepted market rates, but added: "[Bankers] have to earn the money and add value to the company and add value to the shareholder."
The problem faced by ING is familiar to all second-tier banks. Bulge-bracket profits can be elusive, but to retain top staff, pay must remain competitive.
Maas appeared confident that defections would at least be stemmed until the payment of bonuses in February. He hinted that the bank has until this date to clarify its future in investment banking.
But this may be overly optimistic. "Wind this forward 12 months and there will be one or two discreet units, like the Charterhouse business, still operating. The rest will be left to wither on the vine," says one leading banking analyst. "Frankly, if I were an employee I would be on the telephone to a headhunter soon."
For top staff, headhunters may save them the bother. "Phones are ringing all day long," says one insider.
The mood is in sharp contrast to the policy statements on ING's website, which promise staff: "We'll do all we can to foster your potential while offering global opportunities that other institutions can only dream about."