Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Is there any point applying for jobs through recruitment firms now?

More Singaporeans needed in top front-office jobs

The sands have been shifting with regards to financial services 'recruitment channels'. Once upon a time, banks did a lot of their hiring through financial services recruitment firms. Now they don't.

UBS is a case in point. When the Swiss bank presented its first quarter results last month, it said recruiters were used to fill no more than 10% of its jobs in 2012, down from 16% in 2011. Even William Vereker, the big-name M&A banker whom UBS has reportedly hired from Nomura, is said to have been brought on board without the intervention of headhunting firms. UBS declined to comment as to whether this was the case, but it is not the only bank to hire directly - at our recent round tables for banks' heads of recruitment, recruiters said they do 70-75% of their hiring themselves.

Where does this leave recruitment companies and headhunters? In a difficult place is the predictable answer. When the PageGroup, owner of recruitment firm Michael Page, published its first quarter results this week, its share price fell by almost 7%. Gross profits were down 13% year-on-year in Europe, the Middle East and Africa profits from finance and accounting searches globally were down by 7% - more than any other sector except marketing, sales and retail. Meanwhile, recruitment firm Robert Walters has diversified away from its banking roots and now generates 85% of its profits outside of the financial services sector.

Top headhunters are struggling too. Global revenues at Heidrick & Struggles fell 18% in the fourth quarter of 2012 versus the same period of 2011. Kevin Kelly, Heidrick's chief executive officer, cited "challenging economic conditions and lower confirmations," as the source of the disappointment. More generally, banks' in-house recruiters say headhunting firms are being stretched by banks' unwillingness to pay so-called retainers, in which headhunters receive an upfront fee while they set about identifying suitable candidates. "We still offer retainers, but we're only paying one for every three-or-so candidates," the head of recruitment at one international bank told us at a recent round table event.  In the past, banks paid retainers for every candidate, he added. Retainers were typically equivalent to a third of the overall fee, said the head of one recruitment firm - and that fee was calculated on the basis of a third of a candidate's total first year pay.

Why recruiters say candidates should apply through them

Recruitment firms are fighting back, however. Senior recruiters at Selby Jennings - a financial services recruitment firm, and at Michael Page, said there are several very good reasons for candidates to apply for jobs through recruiters. These include the facts that:

1. Left on their own, candidates can go astray

"We often find that candidates develop a distorted view of the market based on hearsay, misdirected advice or limited personal experience," Steve Yendell, managing director at financial services recruiter Selby Jennings, told us. "Engaging with a specialist recruiter provides candidates with an impartial overview of the market, as well as an objective analysis of particular career moves in relation to desired career aspirations."

2. Some banks only hire through recruiters

David Leithead, managing director of Michael Page Financial Services, said that whilst some banks do a "fair amount of direct recruitment," others do "almost none."

This being the case, Leithead warned that, "a jobseeker who decides not to use a recruitment firm is seriously limiting their options." He did not say which banks prefer to use recruiters, however.

3. If you don't use a recruiter, you'll have to negotiate your salary all on your own

Most candidates have a "strong aversion" to negotiating their own pay, said Leithead. If you use a recruiter, you won't need to confront this issue.

Recruiters provide candidates with, "critical support in negotiating fair compensation models," said Yendell.

4. Recruitment firms will allow you to access lots of jobs at once 

If you make yourself known to a recruitment firm instead of applying directly for a job at a single bank, you will be able to access a broader array of potential employers.

"Recruiters provide candidates with a far wider spectrum of opportunity," pointed out Yendell. "Once someone decides to look at opportunities, they almost always want to consider more than one option, and recruitment companies give them that access," said Leithead.

AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • Yo
    15 October 2014

    Simple equation.

    If you have contact many recruiters and have not heard back, you are not a good profile.
    Many recruiters cannot all be wrong.

    If you are putting negative comments on here, you are not a good profile either. Those who have had good experiences with recruiters are busy making loads of money in their new jobs, not spreading their sour grapes around on the internet.

    If you are not a good profile, please don't waste recruiters time any more.

  • SJ
    25 April 2013

    Dear All, I appreciate all of the comments registered, and would welcome the opportunity to speak directly to any individuals who do not feel they have had the experience they expected with Selby Jennings. I would like to counter some of the points raised by saying that, as an organisation both in Singapore and globally, we have an extremely successful track record in finding the best solution for clients on specialist roles. We do not purport to be a generalist supplier, we screen and present the most suitable candidates, and ultimately it is our clients that make the hiring decisions. This does not however allow any unprofessional or discourteous behaviour, and so I would repeat by invitation to any who feels they have experienced this to contact me directly. I will then be able to review your specific case, and ensure that you feel you have been communicated with in a respectful manner.

  • Si
    24 April 2013

    I totally agree to the comments made above.
    1) Usually recruiter is a diploma holder from some no name uni in "garbage cleaning"
    2) It will usually take 3 recruiters to get a 3 digit IQ.
    3) There most imp job is to do a word matching from JD to a resume. For them Investment banking and " M&A /IPO and capital raising" are two different words.
    4) They are more arrogant than billion dollar P&L holding trader.
    4) SELBY JENNINGS in Singapore takes the CAKE (Sorry for caps, just there to make the point).
    ake the point).

  • Cr
    22 April 2013

    Financial recruiters employ sales people who, only a few years ago, might be selling double glazing. Any reputable employer would not wish to be associated with these firms.

    No longer fit for purpose, an added distortion in an already distorted marketplace.

    Good riddance!

    However, I do have some sympathy for some of the poor so and so's who's only way to make a living is to work in recruitment. A horrible job..

  • ga
    22 April 2013

    these monkeys are a giving us candidates a different perspective of the industry when that may not be necessarily true...why am I being put forward for contract roles when I can be pitched for perm roles based on my work exp...reason I am told is "because I do not have local experience"...what??
    I have worked in the most dynamic economies (Aus and GCC) and if I was to move to a country like Singapore...what does 'lack of local experience' exactly mean when fundamentally the nature of my role is the same in any country?
    These guys are becoming directors,managing directors, founder of recruitment firms (Managing Director/Founder) at tender ages of 31/32/33....its a fish market!
    And as someone righty said...barriers to entry are a must!!
    To add on to that...these recruitment firms need to employ 'consultants' who have had a career curve and not just a straight forward someone straight out of Big 4 after 2-3 years, becomes Senior Consultant for accounting/finance roles with Hays,Rob Walters,Talent 2 and other fancy names and is so plastic in his/her approach...can tell you this from personal experience.

Sign up to our Newsletter!

Get advice to help you manage and drive your career.

Boost your career

Find thousands of job opportunities by signing up to eFinancialCareers today.
Latest Jobs
Euroclear Settlement Specialist
Elizabeth, United States
Fed Finance Banque de Marché
Gestionnaire Titrisation F/H
Fed Finance Banque de Marché
St. Louis, United States
CME Group
Quality Assurance Analyst Intern - Summer 2024
CME Group
Chicago, United States
CME Group
Credit Risk Analyst
CME Group
Chicago, United States
CME Group
IT Audit Manager, Global Assurance
CME Group
Chicago, United States

Sign up to our Newsletter!

Get advice to help you manage and drive your career.