Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Recruiter Pet Peeves - Are You Guilty?

You might be pulling your hair out wondering why you can't get a response to your resume. Or why interviews go nowhere. Well, your recruiter doesn't wonder. Some egregious behaviors drive headhunters and hiring managers nuts - not to mention sabotage your job search.

"In the beginning of my career I gave everyone the benefit of doubt," says Ron Reuven, a New York financial planner who has hired hundreds of people. "But when someone lists things that are not relevant on their resume, or doesn't pay attention to getting a professional e-mail address, that tells me a lot about a person."

Technology Is Your Friend. Don't Use It To Make Enemies

Adrienne Graham heads the finance diversity recruitment firm Hues Consulting & Management. She's a big fan of social media - if used strategically and appropriately. Nothing ticks her off more than people who, instead of providing a resume and cover letter, instruct her to check out their profile on a social media site, especially a Facebook page. "I believe in using social media to brand yourself, but it does not replace a resume which shows me what you've accomplished in your career," Graham says. Similarly, the online video resumes she recently received for an administrative assistant position mean a swift press of the "Delete" button.

Ruthanne Feinberg, who heads the HR practice at Glocap Search, seconds Graham's feelings on social networking. She can't stand when candidates send a hiring manager a friend invitation on a social media site during the interview process. "It is not appropriate," Feinberg says. "Don't even get me started on sending friend requests on Facebook."

Reuven bristles when candidates list Microsoft Office as a skill. "In this day and age Word and Excel are not exactly a unique skill," he says. "If you're working on a farm it's not necessary, but if you're working in corporate America, it's a basic requirement."

Reuven is also quick to eliminate candidates who have grossly inappropriate e-mail addresses - those with handles like "loverboy" or "sexymama6969." "I've seen some of the craziest e-mail addresses," he says. "I cannot believe people don't realize that is not professional."

Interview Faux Pas

While it may seem obvious, recruiters list gum chewing, tardiness and cell phone answering during interviews as commonly observed no-nos.

So is being combative with the interviewer, says Bill Liguori, partner at Leadership Capital Group. "We don't normally put people through to the interview who are constantly challenging the person asking questions," Liguori says, explaining the habit as a defense mechanism in situations where the candidate doesn't know how to respond. "It's the 'if you don't have an answer, challenge the question' syndrome,'" he says.

Recruiter Carolyn Dougherty tires of candidates repeatedly billing themselves as "strategic" - and failing to qualify it. "Their intentions are good and they're trying to sound impressive, but it doesn't help them at all," she says. Instead, candidates need to qualify their accomplishments with specific examples of how they saved or made their employers money. "What is the bottom line - were you strategic because the CEO wanted it done, or because you decided 'strategic' is a great word and you need to use it a lot in your interview?" Dougherty says. "You're competing with so many people these days you really need to be on your toes."

More generally, several recruiters complained about candidates' inability to articulate their accomplishments and goals. "It's shouldn't take 20 minutes to walk me through your resume," Feinberg says. "There is an art to getting to the point. Answer the question being asked, then stop talking. Let me be in the driver's seat in an interview."

Resume Madness

Feinberg has a revulsion to e-mailed resumes with non-traditional fonts and backgrounds. "I can't stand that," she says. "Don't try to be different or cute with columns and small text. I want the information to be easy to find. Unless you're applying for a job as a graphic designer, send your resume as a plain Word document or PDF."

Catherine Palmiere, president of Adam Personnel, says she can't stand it when candidates write "to present" on their resume and are no longer working at the firm. "It makes you question what else they are hiding," Palmiere says. "Of course you always have more advantages when you are employed and looking for a job, but let's face it - a lot of people today are unemployed and they are still getting interviews and jobs."

It also irks Palmiere when candidates write their resumes in the third-person. "It shouldn't be an obituary about your life," she says. "Writing in the third-person makes it look like you're making yourself sound more important than you are."

General Annoyances

Liguori says there is a saying in the recruiting industry: candidates are like fresh fish - they spoil after five days.

"Candidates tend to be highly engaged at the start of the process, but after a few weeks they get bored, they don't want to travel to interviews, and their window of availability gets smaller. They need to realize they are the candidate and they have to maintain interest and flexibility."

On the flip side, Feinberg gets irritated with hyper-aggressive candidates who send an e-mail and follow up with a phone call three minutes later. "It's too much," she says. "Following up and showing enthusiasm are great, but be mindful that just because you're anxious to get a job doesn't mean that the position is all that the other party is thinking about."

Another deal-breaker: e-mails that start with, "Since I haven't heard from you ..." "That puts anyone on the defensive right away," Feinberg says. "Practicing patience is important."

AUTHOREmma Johnson Insider Comment
  • Re
    16 September 2010

    It seems like many of the people that made comments on this article have listed MS office as a skill on their resume. that could only mean 1 of 2 things. either you are very young and are looking for a low level job. 2, you really believe it is a skill. Rather than argue the point, I would just suggest that instead of listing MS office as a skill, you can just say that you computer proficient somewhere in the resume without clearly stating that you believe it is a skill. you can either put it somewhere in the job description of your prior jobs or in your letter accompanying the resume. either way IT SHOULD NOT BE LISTED AS A SKILL. it is a neccessity, just like thinking is. this should not be insulting, but rather a new bit of free information and advice. good luck

  • Sa
    5 August 2010

    I agree with Joshua regarding lack of response to resumes. I think companies and recruiters are doing a very, very poor job responding to candidates. But these same companies and recruiters expect you to be professional!

  • jb
    5 August 2010

    After job hunting for 2 years since Macquarie Bank, USA shut down its US Mortgage Division, reformatting my resume hundreds of times, trying to be specific about my accomplishments and experience and abilities, (including IT and software proficiency), I give up!! The bottom line is: most of the time the jobs you are applying for aren't really there. They are being advertised for Federal Compliance regulations to keep the companies out of trouble with EEO. If they are real jobs, the chances of your resume, no matter how experienced and knowlegeable you are in the field, being read at all are slim to none, with an interview either by phone or in person even slimmer. When I have managed to get an interview, I am looking across a desk at someone barely out of college who sees me as washed up due to my age and a threat to their position due to my experience and expertise. If you are over 30, forget finding a job unless you have a personal relationship with the hiring manager or someone who is politically connected to the hiring process.

  • Pa
    4 August 2010

    Bob and Jon,

    I agree with both of you. And as I understand we are to list all of the computer software skills we've obtained throughout our careers. Or is it just assumed that we have these skills be each prospective employer who views our Resumes?

  • Aa
    4 August 2010

    Any search on the dos and don'ts of job hunting returns the same advice written above. A position-relevant resume, a professional-sounding email address, really? Just as the experts are aghast that anyone would commit such mistakes, so too are the majority of this article's readers. With all due respect, more insightful advice would be appreciated.

    Rather than listing these unlikely mistakes, can you give specific examples of what people have done to really knock your socks off? What makes the difference between a "thank you for your interest, but we regret to inform you..." and a "we want you..." letter? Nobody knows the answer to every question, so what is an effective approach to answering a question to which you don't know the answer?

    I graduated a year ago, so I don't have the professional experiences that prove my strategic ability that interviewers want. They have even disregarded my collegiate accomplishments as not real-life enough. How can I, along with all the other disgruntled college grads with budding ambitions, market the value of my potential in a strategic way, of course?

    Finally, elaborate on how to learn "the art of getting to the point".

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Boost your career

Find thousands of job opportunities by signing up to eFinancialCareers today.
Latest Jobs
BNY  Mellon
Business Compliance Officer
BNY Mellon
Pittsburgh, United States
AXA Investment Managers
Compliance Officer
AXA Investment Managers
New York, United States
eFinancialCareers Sourcing Services
Controller (Relocate to Atlanta)
eFinancialCareers Sourcing Services
Boston, United States
eFinancialCareers Sourcing Services
Controller (Relocate to Atlanta)
eFinancialCareers Sourcing Services
Chicago, United States

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.